Key Takeaways
New Hampshire courts can divide personal injury recoveries in a divorce. New Hampshire defines property broadly. A personal injury judgment or settlement acquired before divorce may become part of the divisible estate.
The purpose of the award does not automatically protect it from division. New Hampshire does not categorically exclude compensation for pain and suffering, disability, medical expenses, or lost earnings.
Divisible does not necessarily mean divided equally. RSA 458:16-a presumes an equal division is equitable. However, courts may order an unequal distribution when the statutory factors support it.
The injured spouse may ultimately receive the entire recovery. A court can include a personal injury recovery in the divisible estate but still award the entire recovery to the injured spouse.
Timing can matter. The date of the injury alone does not determine whether a recovery is divisible. Courts may consider when a spouse acquired a settlement, judgment, annuity, or other enforceable property right.
Structured settlements require careful analysis. Future payments under a personal injury settlement may constitute divisible property even when payments continue after the divorce.
Evidence can significantly affect the outcome. Medical needs, diminished earning capacity, settlement documents, the parties’ finances, and the history of the marriage may all influence the final distribution.
Personal Injury Recoveries and Divorce in New Hampshire
A New Hampshire court can distribute a personal injury judgment or settlement in a divorce. New Hampshire takes a broad approach to property division under RSA 458:16-a, and the Supreme Court has held that personal injury recoveries acquired before divorce can fall within the divisible estate.
That answer can understandably surprise an injured spouse. Compensation for chronic pain, disability, future medical treatment, or loss of physical abilities can feel intensely personal. Someone who endured an accident may wonder why a spouse could have any claim to money intended to compensate for those injuries.
The legal answer involves more nuance than simply saying the spouses “split” the settlement. New Hampshire law separates two issues. First, does the recovery belong in the divisible estate? Second, how should the court distribute it? A court can include an asset in the divisible estate without awarding half of it to the other spouse.
People often misunderstand this distinction. Some assume that courts automatically divide everything acquired during marriage 50/50. Others assume that compensation for a personal injury always belongs exclusively to the injured spouse. Neither assumption accurately describes New Hampshire law.
Understanding the difference between classification and distribution can reduce much of this uncertainty. New Hampshire’s property statute and appellate decisions provide the framework for both issues.
How New Hampshire Law Treats Personal Injury Recoveries in Divorce
RSA 458:16-a Defines Property Broadly
New Hampshire’s property-division statute, RSA 458:16-a, broadly defines property. It includes tangible and intangible property and assets belonging to either or both spouses, regardless of how they hold title.
Unlike some jurisdictions, New Hampshire does not automatically exclude an asset because one spouse acquired it individually. Even property acquired before marriage can enter the divisible estate. The source and timing of the property may still affect how the court ultimately divides it.
RSA 458:16-a creates a presumption that an equal division of property is equitable. That does not require a court to divide every individual asset equally. A judge may order an unequal distribution after considering the statutory factors and explaining the reasons for doing so.
Those factors include the length of the marriage and the parties’ age and health. Courts may also consider occupation, employability, income, needs, liabilities, and opportunities to acquire future assets and income. Other factors include contributions during the marriage, certain tax consequences, property brought into the marriage, inherited or gifted property, and other relevant circumstances.
Several factors can carry particular significance when a divorce involves personal injury proceeds. An injured spouse may have permanent physical limitations or diminished earning capacity. That spouse may also face continuing treatment expenses or a reduced ability to accumulate future assets. Those circumstances may support an unequal distribution.
Preston Established the Rule for Personal Injury Settlements
The New Hampshire Supreme Court directly addressed personal injury proceeds in In the Matter of Preston & Preston, 147 N.H. 48 (2001). The case involved personal injury proceeds that the injured spouse received through an annuity.
The Court rejected an approach that classified portions of a settlement according to the particular loss each portion compensated. Under that alternative approach, a court might treat compensation for lost marital earnings differently from compensation for personal pain and suffering.
Instead, Preston applied the broad definition of property under RSA 458:16-a. The Court treated the personal injury recovery as property subject to equitable distribution. It did not require the trial court to separate the settlement into categories based on the underlying damages.
That principle matters because personal injury recoveries often compensate several types of losses. A settlement may address lost earnings, medical expenses, diminished earning capacity, pain and suffering, disability, and future needs. Under Preston, identifying part of the recovery as compensation for pain and suffering does not automatically remove it from the divisible estate.
The 2026 Whitehead Decision Reaffirmed the Rule
The New Hampshire Supreme Court revisited this issue in In the Matter of Whitehead & Whitehead, 2026 N.H. 13 (2026). This decision was issued recently and, at the time of publication, remained within the period for post-decision rehearing procedures.
The husband suffered a spinal cord injury in Canada before meeting his wife. He later received structured-settlement annuities from personal injury litigation. He obtained one annuity before the marriage and another during it. During the divorce, the parties disputed which jurisdiction’s law governed the second annuity. The first annuity vested before the marriage, and was left as the husband’s separate property.
Regarding the second annuity, the Supreme Court applied New Hampshire law and reaffirmed Preston. The Court explained that New Hampshire law treats a personal injury award or settlement obtained before divorce as divisible regardless of its underlying purpose or the loss it replaced.
The timing in Whitehead provides an important lesson. The husband’s injury occurred before the marriage. That fact did not automatically place settlement rights he later acquired beyond equitable distribution.
The accident date therefore does not provide the only relevant date. A court may also examine when the spouse acquired a settlement, judgment, annuity, or other enforceable property right.
Divisible Does Not Mean an Automatic 50/50 Split
Once a personal injury recovery enters the divisible estate, the analysis shifts to equitable distribution under RSA 458:16-a.
The New Hampshire Supreme Court’s decision in In the Matter of Nadeau & Nadeau, 177 N.H. 126 (2024), illustrates this distinction. The wife received approximately $60,000 to $70,000 from a personal injury settlement that occurred after the parties had separated. The settlement arose from a back injury she suffered in an automobile accident. Her husband sought a share of the proceeds.
The Supreme Court recognized the personal injury award as marital property. Nevertheless, it upheld the trial court’s decision effectively awarding the settlement proceeds entirely to the wife because the trial court did consider the proceeds in its calculations, and, in its decision for an equitable division, the trial court granted the proceeds to the wife.
The lesson matters to both spouses. The injured spouse should not assume that the personal nature of the injury makes the recovery legally untouchable. The other spouse should not assume that divisible property creates an automatic right to half of the settlement.
Courts Have Broad Discretion in Distributing Individual Assets
The Supreme Court’s decision, In the Matter of Letendre & Letendre, 149 N.H. 31 (2002), further illustrates the divorce court’s discretion. The Supreme Court considered proceeds arising from the wife’s lawsuit. It recognized that a trial court has discretion to award an individual asset entirely to one spouse if that award is supported by the RSA 458:16-a equitable factors.
New Hampshire property division does not require judges to divide every bank account, house, retirement account, or settlement in half. The court considers the overall marital estate. It can distribute individual assets differently to reach an equitable overall result.
With a personal injury recovery, the court might award the recovery to the injured spouse while allocating other property differently. In another case, the circumstances may support dividing some portion of the recovery itself.
Medical and Financial Evidence Can Affect the Outcome
Equitable distribution depends heavily on the facts. Evidence concerning the injury may therefore become important even though the purpose of the settlement does not determine whether the court can divide it.
Suppose an injured spouse has permanent limitations that substantially reduce future earnings. Medical records and employment evidence may help establish those limitations. Expert opinions, treatment costs, and evidence of diminished earning capacity may also support an unequal distribution.
Settlement agreements and structured-settlement documents also matter. They can establish the amount, timing, ownership, and structure of the recovery. Financial records may show whether the injured spouse kept the proceeds separate, used them to support the household, or converted them into other assets.
Full financial disclosure remains important. A spouse should not omit a personal injury recovery simply because it arose from that spouse’s injuries or remains solely in that spouse’s name.
Pending Personal Injury Claims May Present Different Questions
A pending personal injury claim can create more complicated issues than an established settlement or judgment. If the divorce proceeds while personal injury litigation remains unresolved, the court may need to determine the nature and status of the injured spouse’s existing property interest.
The analysis may differ depending on the status of the claim. A potential claim, filed lawsuit, judgment, executed settlement agreement, and established right to future payments do not necessarily present identical property issues.
Spouses facing simultaneous divorce and personal injury litigation should examine the claim carefully. An unresolved claim may not receive exactly the same treatment as settlement proceeds already received.
Common Examples of Personal Injury Recoveries in Divorce
A Settlement Received During the Marriage
Assume a Manchester resident suffers serious injuries in an automobile accident. The injured spouse receives a $300,000 settlement two years before divorce and keeps most of it in a separately titled account.
The separate account does not automatically exclude the money from property division. Under RSA 458:16-a and Preston, the court can include the recovery in the divisible estate. However, permanent injuries, future treatment costs, and diminished earning capacity could support awarding most or all of the remaining proceeds to the injured spouse.
Compensation for Pain and Suffering
Suppose a settlement expressly identifies a substantial amount as compensation for pain and suffering. The injured spouse argues that the court should exclude the money because the other spouse did not experience the injury.
Under Preston and Whitehead, the purpose of those damages does not automatically remove the money from divisible property. However, the court may consider the personal nature of the loss and the injured spouse’s continuing circumstances when deciding how to distribute the estate.
A Structured Settlement Continuing After Divorce
Consider an injured spouse who receives $4,000 per month from a structured settlement. The payments will continue for another 15 years, well beyond the divorce.
That timing does not necessarily make the annuity non-divisible. Preston and Whitehead demonstrate that established rights to future payments can constitute property subject to equitable distribution. The parties may need to address both the value of those payments and how the court should account for them.
The Injured Spouse Receives the Entire Settlement
Suppose a spouse receives $75,000 after suffering a significant back injury. The spouse continues to experience pain and physical limitations when the parties divorce.
The court does not necessarily have to give the other spouse $37,500. As Nadeau demonstrates, a court may include the settlement in the divisible estate but award the entire recovery to the injured spouse when the circumstances support that result.
Settlement Proceeds Were Used During the Marriage
Assume a Bedford couple benefited from a $200,000 personal injury settlement five years before divorce. By the time the marriage ends, they have spent $150,000 on mortgage payments, household expenses, renovations, and a vehicle.
The divorce court does not necessarily reconstruct the original settlement as though the parties had never spent it. Instead, the court may consider the remaining proceeds, assets purchased with the funds, and the parties’ financial history. Allegations that either spouse improperly dissipated assets may also become relevant.
Fictional Fact Pattern: A Structured Settlement and Long-Term Disability
Sarah and David have been married for 18 years and live in Bedford. Twelve years into their marriage, Sarah’s car is hit by another vehicle that crosses the center line. Sarah suffers serious injuries.
After several surgeries, Sarah eventually returns to work on a reduced schedule. She settles her personal injury case for $900,000. After paying fees and medical obligations, she uses part of the recovery to fund a structured settlement. The settlement pays her $5,000 per month for 15 years.
The settlement documents state that the recovery addresses pain and suffering, medical expenses, lost earning capacity, and other damages. They do not assign a precise amount to every category.
Four years later, David files for divorce. Sarah argues that the court should not divide the remaining annuity. She emphasizes that she suffered the injuries, continues to experience pain, and has permanently reduced earning capacity. David responds that Sarah obtained the annuity during the marriage and used its payments to help support their household.
Under RSA 458:16-a, Preston, and Whitehead, the personal nature of Sarah’s injuries does not categorically exclude the annuity from the divisible estate. The court can treat her established annuity rights as property subject to equitable distribution. This remains true even though portions of the settlement compensated Sarah personally.
Distribution requires a separate analysis. Sarah presents medical records documenting permanent restrictions. She also shows that she can work only 25 hours per week and expects future treatment expenses. David presents evidence that the annuity supported the family while his earnings allowed the parties to increase their retirement savings.
The court would consider those facts along with the rest of the marital estate and the factors in RSA 458:16-a. Sarah’s health, reduced employability, future financial needs, and diminished earning capacity could support an unequal distribution in her favor.
The court might therefore include the annuity in the divisible estate but award Sarah substantially more than half, or potentially all, of that asset. It could then distribute other property in a manner it considers equitable. Classifying the annuity as divisible property does not dictate its ultimate distribution.
Frequently Asked Questions About Personal Injury Recoveries and New Hampshire Divorce
Is a Personal Injury Settlement Marital Property in New Hampshire?
A personal injury settlement acquired before divorce can become part of the property subject to equitable distribution under RSA 458:16-a. Preston and Whitehead establish that the purpose of the damages does not automatically exempt the recovery.
Does My Spouse Automatically Get Half of My Settlement?
No. New Hampshire presumes an equal property division is equitable, but courts can order an unequal distribution based on the statutory factors. Nadeau demonstrates that a court may award the injured spouse the entire recovery in appropriate circumstances.
What If the Settlement Is Only in My Name?
Holding the settlement solely in your name does not automatically exclude it from the divisible estate. RSA 458:16-a broadly encompasses property belonging to either or both spouses.
What If the Accident Happened Before We Married?
The accident date alone does not necessarily control how the settlement would be divided. Whitehead involved an injury that predated the marriage. The case illustrates the importance of determining when the injured spouse acquired the relevant settlement or property rights.
Is Compensation for Pain and Suffering Divisible?
Potentially. New Hampshire does not automatically exclude settlement proceeds simply because they compensate an injured spouse for pain and suffering.
What About Money for Future Medical Care?
The intended purpose of the money does not necessarily exclude it from divisible property. However, the court may consider continuing medical needs and the injured spouse’s financial circumstances when deciding how to divide the estate.
Can Future Structured-Settlement Payments Be Divided?
Yes. Established rights to future payments can fall within the property subject to equitable distribution. Both Preston and Whitehead involved structured personal injury recoveries.
What If I Receive My Settlement After We Separate?
Physical separation alone does not necessarily determine whether the settlement enters the divisible estate. The court may need to examine when the underlying property right arose and its nature under New Hampshire law.
Do I Have to Disclose My Personal Injury Settlement?
A spouse should disclose a personal injury recovery when it forms part of the financial circumstances relevant to the divorce. Holding the settlement individually does not justify omitting an otherwise reportable asset from required financial disclosures.
Can a Personal Injury Settlement Affect Child Support?
Potentially. Property division and child support involve different legal analyses. New Hampshire appellate decisions, including In the Matter of State & Taylor, 153 N.H. 700 (2006), have addressed the inclusion of personal injury proceeds when determining income for child-support purposes.
Final Thoughts
New Hampshire courts can include personal injury judgments and settlements in the property they divide during a divorce. That does not mean the court will automatically divide the recovery equally between the spouses. New Hampshire law separates the classification of an asset from its ultimate distribution.
Under RSA 458:16-a and decisions including Preston, Nadeau, and Whitehead, courts have considerable discretion to evaluate the circumstances surrounding the recovery. They can also consider the parties’ broader financial circumstances. The injured spouse’s health, future medical needs, earning capacity, and financial prospects may all influence the result.
For anyone facing divorce with a significant personal injury judgment, settlement, or structured payment, understanding the recovery’s place within the overall marital estate is essential. Careful documentation and a complete financial picture give the court the information it needs to reach an equitable result under New Hampshire law.
About the Author: Damian Turco is the Founder and Managing Partner of Turco Legal and has practiced divorce and family law since 2008.
Damian Turco’s Bio Page | More Blogs from Damian Turco
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as legal advice. Articles on our blog are written at a historical point in time and the information presented accurately reflects the law at the time of the article’s writing. If you’d like to better understand how the law applies to your case, schedule an attorney consultation by calling any of our offices or by clicking the Schedule a Consultation link on this page.
