Turco Legal, P.C.
  • About
    • Our Approach
    • Client Testimonials
    • For Students
      • Scholarship
      • Marketing Internship
      • Choosing a Legal Practice Area
    • More Justice, Together | Turco Legal + Lawyers for Civil Rights
    • Careers
    • Family Law Videos
    • Why We Underwrite on NPR and WBUR Boston
    • What’s a Certified Financial Litigator?
  • Our Team
    • Damian J. Turco
    • Maureen Booth
    • Jessica MacRae Sousa
    • Kristin Sherman
    • Akosua Agyepong
    • Melissa Fay
    • Erin Fitch Nielson
    • Effie Gikas Tchobanian
    • Amanda Gnau
    • Theresa Gomes
    • Kathleen Murphy
    • Brian Waller
    • Andrea Wells
    • Ariana Bond
    • Nicoletta Longo
    • Meenah Keenan
    • Tailayah Macklin
    • Lyndsey Schall
  • Practice Areas
    • Divorce & Family Law
      • Physical Custody and Visitation
      • Legal Custody
      • Child Support
      • Alimony
      • Property Division
      • Military Divorce
      • Same-Sex Divorce
    • Mediation
      • Stubborn Spouse
      • College Expenses Disputes
      • Child Custody Disputes
      • Marital Home Issue
      • Will Divorce Mediation Work in My Case?
    • Modifications
    • Contempt
    • Restraining Orders
    • Adoption
    • Appeals
  • Offices
    • Andover
    • Boston
    • Newburyport
    • Newton
    • Worcester
  • Blog
  • Pricing
    • Pricing & Payments
    • Justice for All Reduced-Fee LAR Program
  • (866) 995-6663
Select Page

IRA Accounts and Romantic Partners

by Turco Legal | Oct 8, 2018 | Alimony, Child Support, Equitable Distribution

As divorce attorneys, we often see litigation and settlement questions regarding individual retirement accounts (IRAs). A pension plan, IRA, or other type of account is considered marital property for purposes of distribution during a divorce.

New questions may arise, however, where unmarried persons engaged in a romantic partnership seek to designate each other as beneficiaries of an IRA. In a recent opinion, the Massachusetts Appeals Court addressed an issue concerning an IRA beneficiary. The beneficiary was the former romantic partner of the decedent whose IRA account was in question.

Background:

In UBS Financial Services, Inc. v. Aliberti, three different IRA accounts were in question. These were in the amounts of $31,000, $18,000, and $276,000, respectively. The account holder originally designated his romantic partner (party to the suit) as beneficiary of all three accounts.

In November 2013, the account holder expressed a desire to name additional beneficiaries. He sent back completed and signed designation update forms for the two smaller accounts, but not the third one. The updated forms designated an additional primary beneficiary and two additional contingent beneficiaries; they also indicated that each beneficiary should receive a 25% share of the account proceeds.

UBS asked the account holder to clarify whether he meant to list each of the four as primary beneficiaries. The account holder did not respond and unexpectedly died the following month. The romantic partner then contacted the account administrator regarding each of the IRA accounts; she requested the distribution of all funds to her as the sole beneficiary.

Who gets the money?

The administrator of the accounts happened to be the decedent’s former sister-in-law, who worked at UBS as a financial advisor. The beneficiary reached out to the administrator to check on the status of her claim. However, the administrator never provided a status update. Instead, she sent to the beneficiary several nasty text messages. These included: “How big of a whore are you,” “You are the most worst piece of filth I have ever encountered,” and, “Are you so eager to grab the money. Did you even notice his death certificate is wrong? Oh no you were too busy ransacking.”

The Court agreed with the beneficiary that UBS unlawfully withheld from her the proceeds from the largest IRA account; the Court noted UBS never received any documentation naming anyone other than the romantic partner as beneficiary for that account. “Considering the time value of money and the fact that no investment decisions were made regarding the largest IRA for over two and one-half years, the facts alleged in the pleadings support the inference that [the beneficiary] likely was damaged from the delay in distributing those funds,” the Appeals Court held. Accordingly, the Court held that the beneficiary properly pleaded her breach of contract claims.

Fiduciary duty:

Additionally, the Court held that the beneficiary also properly pleaded claims for breach of fiduciary duty. It stated that a fiduciary relationship existed between the decedent and UBS. “As a fiduciary, UBS was obligated to administer the IRAs for the exclusive benefit of [the beneficiary] (assuming the truth of [her] allegation that she was the only proper beneficiary) while acting fairly and in her best interests,” the Court stated, holding that UBS was required to timely distribute the IRA proceeds to the beneficiary and to keep her otherwise informed of their status.

Other claims:

The Appeals Court then held that the beneficiary’s claims for infliction of emotional distress were not sufficient and should be dismissed. On the issue of violation of the Massachusetts consumer protection statutes, however, the Court again held for the beneficiary. “Based on the pleadings here, UBS … (1) denied Aliberti the funds to which she was entitled; (2) for multiple years; (3) without good reason; (4) until she was forced to take legal action and incur unnecessary costs and fees,” the Court noted. It held that those actions constituted a violation of Massachusetts General Laws chapter 93A.

Contact us:

Are you looking for an experienced Newburyport or Andover divorce lawyer? Have questions or concerns about issues involving family law, domestic relations, or other legal issues? Contact a competent attorney. Turco Legal has experience in a variety of areas of divorce and family law. Our divorce, family, and domestic relations attorneys may be able to work on your behalf to handle your case. We have offices in Andover, Newburyport, Newton, and Boston. Contact us by phone at 978-225-9030 during business hours to schedule a free consultation.

 

Click Here to Schedule a Free Phone or Zoom Consultation

Recent Posts

  • Massachusetts Appeals Court Affirms Major Support Increases in High-Income Divorce Case
  • Voluntary Acknowledgments and Legal Finality
  • Domestic Relations Reform: MA Courts Update
  • De Facto Parents – Massachusetts Parentage Act
  • International Parental Kidnapping Prevention Tips

Categories

  • Adoption
  • Agreements
  • Alimony
  • Annulment
  • Appeals
  • Attorney's Fees
  • Child Support
  • Contempt
  • Custody
  • DCF
  • Declaratory Judgment
  • Divorce
  • Equitable Distribution
  • Guardianship
  • Jurisdiction
  • Mediation
  • Modification
  • Prenuptial Agreement
  • Removal
  • Restraining Order
  • Separation
  • Uncategorized

Andover Office

(978) 699-0040
2 Elm Square, Suite 315
Andover, MA 01810

Boston Office

(617) 657-4878
50 Congress Street, Suite 420
Boston, MA 02109

Newburyport Office

(978) 225-9030​
29 Water Street, Suite 301
Newburyport, MA 01950

Worcester Office

(508) 986-9966
250 Commercial Street, Suite 200
Worcester, MA 01608

  • About
  • Our Team
  • Practice Areas
  • Offices
  • Blog
  • Pricing
  • (866) 995-6663
© Turco Legal PC, 2025 | All Rights Reserved. This website is for informational purposes; it does not constitute legal advice.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
Cookie SettingsAccept
Manage consent

Cookie Policy

We use cookies to help improve your experience of our website at https://turcolegal.com/. This cookie policy is part of Turco Legal, PC's privacy policy. It covers the use of cookies between your device and our site.

We also provide basic information on third-party services we may use, who may also use cookies as part of their service. This policy does not cover their cookies.

If you don’t wish to accept cookies from us, you should instruct your browser to refuse cookies from https://turcolegal.com/. In such a case, we may be unable to provide you with some of your desired content and services.

What is a cookie?
A cookie is a small piece of data that a website stores on your device when you visit. It typically contains information about the website itself, a unique identifier that allows the site to recognize your web browser when you return, additional data that serves the cookie’s purpose, and the lifespan of the cookie itself.

Cookies are used to enable certain features (e.g. logging in), track site usage (e.g. analytics), store your user settings (e.g. time zone, notification preferences), and to personalize your content (e.g. advertising, language).

Cookies set by the website you are visiting are usually referred to as first-party cookies. They typically only track your activity on that particular site.

Cookies set by other sites and companies (i.e. third parties) are called third-party cookies They can be used to track you on other websites that use the same third-party service.

Types of cookies and how we use them:
Essential cookies
Always Enabled
Essential cookies are crucial to your experience of a website, enabling core features like user logins, account management, shopping carts, and payment processing. We use essential cookies to enable certain functions on our website.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functionality cookies
Functionality cookies are used to collect information about your device and any settings you may configure on the website you’re visiting (like language and time zone settings). With this information, websites can provide you with customized, enhanced, or optimized content and services. These cookies may be set by the website you’re visiting (first-party) or by third-party services. We use functionality cookies for selected features on our site.
Performance cookies
Performance cookies track how you use a website during your visit. Typically, this information is anonymous and aggregated, with information tracked across all site users. They help companies understand visitor usage patterns, identify and diagnose problems or errors their users may encounter, and make better strategic decisions in improving their audience’s overall website experience. These cookies may be set by the website you’re visiting (first-party) or by third-party services. They do not collect personal information about you. We use performance cookies on our site.
Analytical cookies
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Targeting/advertising cookies
Targeting/advertising cookies help determine what promotional content is most relevant and appropriate to you and your interests. Websites may use them to deliver targeted advertising or limit the number of times you see an advertisement. This helps companies improve the effectiveness of their campaigns and the quality of content presented to you. These cookies may be set by the website you’re visiting (first-party) or by third-party services. Targeting/advertising cookies set by third-parties may be used to track you on other websites that use the same third-party service. We use targeting/advertising cookies on our site.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT